What Happens When Churches Actually Answer Their Phone (55% Are Missing Out)

🛎️ What Happens When Churches Actually Answer the Phone?

Some churches are seeing visitor retention double — from 9% to over 20% — just by answering their phones consistently. Others are missing life-changing ministry moments simply because nobody picked up the call.

Here’s the real kicker: Barna Research found that 55% of churches can’t connect callers with help during regular business hours. That means over half of churches are missing key ministry opportunities every single day.

‍

‍

This blog breaks down why that matters — and what you can do about it.

📊 The Real Numbers (And Why They Matter)

• 55% couldn’t connect callers to a real person during business hours.
• 67% of people who reach voicemail hang up and never call back.
• Churches that answer consistently retain over 20% of first-time visitors (vs. just 9%).

These aren’t just stats — they represent real people who never got the help, prayer, or information they needed.

📞 What Happens When People Can Actually Reach You

1. Better Visitor Retention

• Growing churches retain about 20% of first-time visitors.
• Non-growing churches retain around 9%.
• Follow-up communication — including calls — is the difference.

2. Real-Time Crisis Ministry

• During COVID, crisis-line calls to churches rose 20%.
• Churches that answered made a difference. The ones that didn’t missed ministry moments.

3. Small Churches Win Big

• 70% of U.S. churches have under 100 members.
• Smaller churches benefit most when every call counts.
• Answering calls is a low-cost, high-impact way to connect.

💰 The Money Part (It’s Better Than You Think)

Worried about cost? Don’t be.

• AI-powered answering services average around $38/month.
• That’s less than most churches spend on coffee.
• Compare that to hiring someone part-time — which can cost thousands.

Churches using services like ChurchCalls.ai:

• Retain more visitors
• Increase member engagement
• Capture ministry opportunities they’d otherwise miss

🌍 This Is a Cultural Shift

Today’s world expects organizations to be reachable.

Churches that answer the call — literally — are seen as helpful, present, and relevant.

It’s not about technology for technology’s sake. It’s about ministry, accessibility, and trust.

Those who adapt are growing. Those who don’t aren’t bad churches — they’re just missing opportunities they may not even realize.
‍

🔧 What This Means for Your Church

If someone called your church right now… would they reach someone who can help?

If the answer is “I don’t know” or “Probably voicemail,” you’ve got a big opportunity.

• This isn’t about spending money you don’t have.
• It’s about making a small change that could transform how people experience your church.
• In a world where everything is automated, the church that answers the phone stands out in the best way.
  ‍

✅ Frequently Asked Questions

Why does answering the phone matter for churches?

Churches that answer calls consistently see visitor retention jump from 9% to over 20%. It also opens the door for ministry moments during crises and helps small churches stay connected with their communities.

How many churches are missing calls?

Barna Research found that 55% of churches couldn’t connect callers to a real person during regular hours. That’s a missed opportunity to serve and engage.

Is this an expensive solution?

Not at all. Church answering services like ChurchCalls.ai start at about $38/month — less than most churches spend on office coffee.

Do small churches benefit from this too?

Yes. In fact, 70% of churches have under 100 members, and small churches often see the biggest impact from improved communication and availability.

What happens when someone calls and can’t reach us?

67% of people who hit voicemail will hang up and move on. But if they get help right away, they’re far more likely to return and get connected.

‍